If I ever ate soup when I was a kid, it was chicken noodle. Never tomato. And never ever anything with weird veggies or other foreign ingredients. But now some of my favorite go-to recipes are soup recipes…chicken wild rice, chicken corn chowder, french onion. Mmmmm. But I still didn’t like tomato soup until my husband begged me to make it for him a few years ago. I always just bought him a can of Campbells and had him make his own, but he asked me to make it from scratch so I found a recipe and gave it a try. And I still don’t love tomato soup on its own, but with gooey grilled cheese to dip in the soup? Heavenly.
I don’t even remember the source of my original tomato basil soup recipe, and I’ve changed it so much from its original version that it’s not even recognizeable anymore, so I’ll just go ahead and call this my own recipe. It’s easy and it has become a staple in our house. We eat it almost weekly. My 19 month old, who does not touch vegetables, loves it. And it’s so much better than condensed can-of-something.
Don’t be alarmed or deterred by the presence of butter and cream in this soup. It is a rich soup and it’s probably not low-fat, but it is delicious and if it makes you feel better, I cut the quantity of both butter and cream in half from the original recipe, and the soup is still rich and amazing, with fewer calories. It’s worth it, trust me. (And I don’t recommend substituting half-n-half or milk for the cream, tempting as it may be. I found out the hard way that the consistency of the soup is terrible without actual cream.)
Creamy Tomato Basil Soup
Ingredients:
- 1 large can (28 oz) diced tomatoes (or about four large fresh tomatoes, chopped)
- 6 cups tomato juice
- generous handful of fresh basil (or about 1 Tbsp dried or freeze-dried basil), or adjusted amount to taste
- 1/2 tsp each salt and pepper (or to taste)
- 1 cup heavy cream
- 4 Tbsp unsalted butter
Combine diced tomatoes and tomato juice in your favorite stock pot and heat on medium-high until boiling. Reduce heat slightly and let the mixture simmer about 20 minutes (longer if using fresh tomatoes), stirring occasionally, until the mixture is slightly reduced and the tomatoes are very soft. Remove from heat. Add the basil to the pot and, using either an immersion blender, or transferring the mixture to a traditional blender, blend the mixture until throughly combined and consistency is smooth. Return to the pot and turn the stove on low. Add the butter and stir until melted, then add the salt, pepper, and cream and stir until combined. Serve immediately and do not boil once the butter and cream are added.
I love serving this with grilled cheese on sourdough bread. It’s the one soup that I don’t eat with crackers or plain bread. Can you see why?